Blog author: jballor
Thursday, April 3, 2008
By

Rod Dreher links to a piece by Cato’s Brink Lindsey, “Culture of Success.” The conclusion of Lindsey’s piece is that familial culture is more important to child success in school and economic achievement than external assistance, in the form of tuition grants or otherwise:

If more money isn’t the answer, what does have an impact? In a word: culture. Everything we know about high performance in all fields of endeavor tells us that, while natural talent is a plus, there is no substitute for long hours of preparation and hard work…. Apply these lessons to doing well in school, and it becomes clear that the class divide in academic achievement is fundamentally a cultural divide. To put it in a nutshell, the upper-middle-class kid grows up in an environment that constantly pushes him to develop the cognitive and motivational skills needed to be a good student; the low-income kid’s environment, on the other hand, pushes in the opposite direction.

Lindsey, to his credit, recognizes the fact that these sorts of trans-generational, cultural and familial concerns typically lie outside the competence of his own libertarian ideological camp:

We insist on the central importance of individual responsibility for the healthy functioning of a free society. Yet, by the time people become legally responsible adults, circumstances not of their own choosing — namely, how they were raised and whom they grew up with — may have prevented them from ever developing the capacities they need to thrive and flourish.

I’m disappointed to find that Lindsey then makes the move to say that on that basis there exists “the possibility that government intervention to improve those circumstances could actually expand the scope of individual autonomy.” I’m not disappointed because the statement is false (it is in fact true), but because the government isn’t the first place we should look to find solutions to cultural problems. What about other institutions, most especially the church?

Dreher’s post is lengthy and worth a read in full, in part because it takes Lindsey’s piece as a point of departure to bring in a number of other insights and sources. Dreher writes of the government’s relation to culture among the poor,

…I don’t believe all the government programs we could possibly imagine will fundamentally change their condition, because their condition is not fundamentally a matter of material deprivation.

Culture is more important than politics, as Moynihan said. But he also said that politics can save a culture from itself. What kind of politics could save inner-city black culture from itself? Ideas? Because we certainly need them in society at large, not just the black inner city.

Dreher also echoes my question: “Here’s what I don’t understand: where are the churches in all this?”

Where are they? If they aren’t actively engaged in responsible urban evangelism, which many are, then they are probably doing (A) nothing or (B) lobbying the government to do something. A is bad and B might be worse.

Dolly Parton was featured on American Idol this week. One of the songs a contestant performed from her body of work was the song, based on her real-life experiences, “Coat of Many Colors,” and it teaches a lesson directly relevant to this topic.


Here’s the last verse, after the children make fun of her for her coat:

But they didn’t understand it
And I tried to make them see
That one is only poor
Only if they choose to be
Now I know we had no money
But I was rich as I could be
In my coat of many colors
My momma made for me
Made just for me


  • http://www.evaneco.com Don Bosch

    Watching her sing “Jesus” at the top of her lovely lungs and imagine the wails from the secular media/audience trying to absorb what she was doing was also amazing. Her credibility in the music and recording industry is unmatched, and yet here is a woman who proclaims her love for Jesus as powerful and real as gravity. Great stuff, Dolly! You go, girl!

  • Ray Nothstine

    Dolly Parton is one of the greatest song writers ever. I love the Christian emphasis and imagery in her music. A lot of her recent albums such as Halos and Horns, Little Sparrow, The Grass is Blue, and Hungry Again is really some of the best traditional country and roots music ever.

  • Clare Krishan

    Rod Dreher has an related and very interesting “bleg” requesting pointers for financially illiterate journalists like himself to understand recent events…

    http://blog.beliefnet.com/crunchycon/2008/04/economics-101.html#preview

    I posted a link under the comments there to your recent MandM article by Edward O’Boyle.

    Perhaps this blog could elaborate for other professionals in similar straights? A Powerblog “Economics 101″?

    The looming crisis in credit insolvency presents the many private and public actors in the civic discourse with the need for advice that is solidly grounded in a philosophy of human personalism rather than ideological fantasy…