Blog author: hunter.baker
Thursday, August 18, 2011
By

Michelle Goldberg has a column up at the aptly named Daily Beast letting us all know that we really need to worry about something called “Dominionism” which supposedly prevails among Michelle Bachmann, Rick Perry, and folks who support their campaigns. Reinhold Niebuhr once warned of the dangers of religious illiteracy. Here we have exhibit A.

Goldberg claims Bachmann and Perry are “deeply associated” with this “theocratic strain” of Christian fundamentalism. Yes, they are probably so deeply associated with it that neither one of them has ever heard of R.J. Rushdoony (whom Goldberg tags as the father of this theocratic movement).

I have been part of organizations of Christian conservatives for many years and can assure Ms. Goldberg that Rushdoony and Christian Reconstructionism (making Hebraic law obligatory upon the broader society) exert very little influence. In fact, I think I can probably argue empirically that Rushdoony has captured the attention of many more liberal reporters with an axe to grind than it has evangelicals. For those of us who spend so much time thinking about political theology as to even have heard of CR, it is primarily a novelty. To view standard issue evangelicals in the same light as Christian Reconstructionists would be like taking rank and file Democrats and comparing them to the most extreme and exotic atheistic socialists.

The overwhelming majority position of Christians around the world is that forced religion is a stench in the nostrils of a holy God. Instead, Christians give their money to sustain people called missionaries. We support their efforts to persuade those who don’t believe in Jesus Christ that he is the son of God and that they should enter into a relationship with him. If those people subsequently refuse to believe in Jesus, missionaries pray for them and move on to other people. Those engaged by missionaries join churches or just keep on doing what they were doing before. It’s actually a pretty non-threatening business. This is the Christian idea Rick Perry and Michelle Bachmann would endorse, not some fever dream of journalists hoping to bring down candidates for office.

Now, is it true that Rick Perry and Michelle Bachmann would like to get elected and attempt to pass some of their aspirations for the good society into law? Certainly. This is a process called politics. It is a feature of democracies. And I suspect what Perry and Bachmann would like to do is reduce the size of government, which, incidentally, is not all that great a danger to individual freedom.

Of course, both are pro-life and would like to protect unborn children from being killed in the womb. If that position is so extreme as to warrant exclusion from the political process and raving condemnations in print . . . well, in that case I’m afraid I can’t do much to help.


  • Jay Hutchens

    It’s more prevalent than you think.  Spend any amount of time watching Christian cable television and there’s a steady diet of dominionism and CR.  Sadly, many conservative Christians in the rural south are fed regularly on this and because it’s “on TV” it has established itself as a norm.

  • Pingback: Coming soon, the U.S. Department of Spiritual Warfare and Inquisition | Unsettled Christianity

  • Roger McKinney

    All Christian media together reach less than 4% of the population.

    Thanks for the post, Hunter! I couldn’t figure out where the socialists were getting such nonsense. Now I know.

  • Jay Hutchens

    I’m thinking of the influence of the “International House of Prayer”, the so-called “Prophetic Movement”, Morning Star Church, Bethel Church.  I’ve run across lots of Christians who are influenced by their teachings directly or indirectly.  Perhaps the most public expose of this is the  movie “Jesus Camp” which highlights the above described movement.  IHOP is broadcast frequently on “GodTV”