Blog author: dpahman
Wednesday, January 4, 2012
By

Source: Wikimedia Commons, Photography by shakko

Over at the Sojourners blog, Harry C. Kiely boldly considers whether the Occupy movement can be considered “the New Pentecost.” However, there are a myriad of problems with his comparison.

First and most importantly, from a Christian point of view, there already has been a “New Pentecost.” It is found in Acts 2. The Christian Pentecost was the fulfillment of the Jewish Pentecost. The giving of the Law (which the Jewish Pentecost commemorates) found its fulfillment in the giving of the Holy Spirit to the Church to write the Law on the hearts of God’s people (see Jeremiah 31:33). Thus, for Kiely to proclaim the Occupy movement a New Pentecost is to already fail to understand what he is attempting to describe.

The theological flubs do not end there, unfortunately. He goes on to write,

In Acts, the emergence of new power occurred when the “gossip” about the Resurrection became a life-empowering message that transcended all lingual differences: “each heard in his own language.” Likewise in Occupy Wall Street: in the development of a new means of communication, people of diverse backgrounds both spoke and heard in a common language. It was, indeed, a New Pentecost.

Apparently the Holy Spirit of God was a “new power” that emerged from “the ‘gossip’ about the Resurrection” and is analogous to the iPhone.

He continues,

Deprived of loud speaker technology, for example, they invented a more human method of broadcast. Because they lacked appointed or elected leaders, the newly evolved community devised ways of organizing. In contrast to Wall Street methodology, the newly resurrected human community shared their food and goods with one another.

Actually, people in the ancient world did have “loud speaker technology”: they called them amphitheaters. As for the supposedly “more human method of broadcast” that “they invented,” I would love to hear how the disciples, in fact, “invented” the Holy Spirit. Furthermore, Kiely’s claim that “they lacked appointed or elected leaders” overlooks the fact that the Apostles were appointed by Christ himself (see Matthew 10:1-4), and, in fact, immediately before the story of Pentecost in Acts 2, the disciples had just deliberated over who would fill Judas Iscariot’s office in the Church and chose Matthias to be his replacement (see Acts 1:12-26).

In addition to misunderstanding the Christian Pentecost in Acts 2, Kiely also misunderstands the Occupy movement, which, despite some criticisms I may have for it, to its credit has never claimed to be a religious awakening of any sort. Indeed, no one in my generation would view it that way, whether they are for or against it. As one commentator (“Crazywulf”) wrote,

Please…please…please…… while whole heartedly supporting Occupy, I don’t believe anyone involved have actually been chosen by our saviour to be part of His inner circle… I know that wasn’t the intention of the author (or I hope it wasn’t)  but it could come off that way….

By contrast, after having completed his comparison, Kiely concludes with, perhaps, the most “Dominionist” statement I have ever read:

Emerging out of the New Pentecost [i.e. Occupy] is the promise of a New Creation that will transcend the endless, hollow, self-destructive promises of raging empires.

Yikes.


  • http://www.remnantculture.com/ Remnant Culture

    Oh. My. Goodness.

  • http://palamas.info/ Fr Gregory Jensen

    Excellent analysis Dylan! Thank you!

    Reading Kiely’s comments, I find myself I wondering what (from a biblical perspective anyway) is more human than the fabrication of goods through the use of reason and the material of creation?  I am at a lost how shouting is more in keeping with human dignity than, say, the use of a public address system.  Animals shout–or at least scream–so with this in mind one could at least argue that (content aside) the use of loud speakers is more fitting to our nature than is shouting and the parroting of each other that we see in the OWS protest.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1060874428 Dylan James O’Brien Pahman

      Thank you for your thank you.

      Indeed, after reading Kiely’s post, I am at a loss to find any logic undergirding any of his comments. I’m sure that he meant well, but I do not think he has accomplished anything good, not to mention intellectually coherent or constructive.

      • http://palamas.info/ Fr Gregory Jensen

        Henri Nouwen in one of his books on ministry comments that sentimentality is the mother of violence. He goes on to explain that this is so because when I view the world sentimentally, I do so through the lens of my own narcissism. Effectively, I see the world–and my neighbor–not as gifts from God which call me to obedience but as objects to be manipulated according to my own, transitory and often self-contradictory, whims.

  • Pingback: Audio: Jordan Ballor on Christian Responses to Occupy Wall Street | @ActonInstitute PowerBlog()

  • http://onlinebiblefree.com/ GerthaBehn

    Thanks for sharing the news about the new Pentecost. I love to join and enjoy this. this info also useful for that people who really want to know about the pentecost.