Acton Institute Powerblog

Is America Too Religious to Be Socialist?

Share this article:
Join the Discussion:

socialism-0916Since its development as a political movement in the 1700s, socialism has spread to numerous nations, especially in Asia and Africa. Yet even when the U.S. government began adopting socialist policies (see: the New Deal), Americans tended to reject any direct connections to socialism. Why is that?

One possible answer may be that America is simply too religious. As Andrew R. Lewis and Paul A. Djupe of FiveThirtyEight explain:

To understand the relationship between socialist values and religion, we used the 2013 Public Religion Research Institute’s “Economic Values Study.” As part of the survey, respondents were asked how much they agreed with a battery of statements regarding economic values, including “It is the responsibility of the government to take care of people who can’t take care of themselves,” The government should do more to reduce the gap between the rich and poor” and “The government should guarantee health insurance for all citizens.” We combined these into a “socialism scale,” the results of which suggest the average American is just left of center.

The conventional wisdom is that the individualist, evangelical style of American religion is a strong antidote to socialism. If faith alone can lead you to salvation, then efforts to reshape society are beside the point. But the animosity between them has been more pointed, especially regarding so called “Godless communists” who portrayed religion as the “opiate of the masses.” In these data, those who agreed that social problems would be resolved if enough people had a personal relationship with God were 20 percent less socialist than those who disagreed. A worldview that pits faith directly against collective action explains clearly why collectivist efforts have traditionally foundered in the U.S.

Based on this data, it’s not surprising that the Americans who are most supportive of socialism are the “nones.” As Lewis and Djupe note, “Nones are 10 percent more socialist, on average, than religious Americans.”

Joe Carter Joe Carter is a Senior Editor at the Acton Institute. Joe also serves as an editor at the The Gospel Coalition, a communications specialist for the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention, and as an adjunct professor of journalism at Patrick Henry College. He is the editor of the NIV Lifehacks Bible and co-author of How to Argue like Jesus: Learning Persuasion from History's Greatest Communicator (Crossway).


  • The US is far more socialist than most people think. The common definitions of socialism is actually the definition of atheistic communism. Because the US isn’t like the old USSR people think we’re not socialist. But there have been many varieties of socialism. The US is most like the fascist Italian socialism. American socialists were smart enough to not call themselves socialist and used “progressive” or “liberal” instead and fooled most Americans.

  • Resbo

    The DEMON-crats have been pushing the Socialist agenda for years. Bernie Sanders is just the first to openly admit it. The fact that he has a large following among young voters is testament to the fact that they know nothing about Socialism and don’t really care as long as they get a “free” college education!

  • rodlarocque1931

    Socialism destroys the grace received through personal acts of Charity. Instead forced-Charity is exacted from the tax-payer and used for purposes that often as a Christian, he does not agree.
    In this sense Socialism is evil, in that it destroys the development of bonds of personal love that should exist within a community.

  • texasknight

    Socialism is state controlled wealth with preferential redistribution of wealth. We are somewhere between a democratic republic and a socialist democracy, but a lot closer to the later. We are headed towards a full blown oligarchy. We no longer own our homes. Try not paying your property tax and see what happens. If you add up all our taxes, we are paying >50% of our earned property (in the form of money). Wake up America!