In his book Elements of Justice (reviewed in the Journal of Markets & Morality here), University of Arizona philosophy and economics professor David Schmidtz introduces the idea of desert not simply as a compensatory notion, but also as including a promissory aspect. That is, what we deserve isn’t always about only what we have done. There might be a real sense in which what we do after an opportunity provides a kind of retroactive justification for having been given a chance.
Posts tagged with: desert
One of my favorite industries to criticize is the state-run lottery business.
Philosopher William F. Vallicella writes the following: “Your chances of a significant win are next-to-nil. But suppose you win, and suppose you manage to not have your life destroyed by your ‘good fortune.’ The winnings are arguably ill-gotten gains. The money was extracted via false advertising from ignorant rubes and is being transferred via a chance mechanism to someone who has done nothing to deserve it” (HT: the evangelical outpost).
In the Last Week
- Everyday Christianity: A Faith Free From The Accidental Pharisaism of Missional, Radical, Crazy and Other Superlatives (1,613 views)
by Anthony Bradley - Why Jesus is (Probably) Not a Keynesian (821 views)
by Joseph Sunde - 'No Religion, Please. We're European.' (507 views)
by Elise Hilton - Narcissism and the Minimum Wage Are Destroying Opportunities (479 views)
by Anthony Bradley - Pathological Altruism: When 'Good Intentions' Aren't So Good (436 views)
by Joseph Sunde
- Acton Commentary (260)
- Acton Media (77)
- Acton University (49)
- Bible and Theology (580)
- Christian Social Thought (267)
- Economic Freedom (77)
- Economics (115)
- General (590)
- Individual Liberty (174)
- Interviews (34)
- News and Events (2344)
- On Call in Culture (55)
- Poverty (122)
- PowerBlog Ramblings (53)
- PowerLinks (133)
- Programs (64)
- Public Policy (2075)
- Publications (214)
- Religious Liberty (39)
- Shareholder Activism (3)
- Shareholder Proxy Resolutions (3)
- Technology (15)
- Vatican (227)
- Virtue (53)
- Vocation (6)